[Mikasa's choice earns her a confused look at first. Rey glances back to the machine's contents, before spotting the plush she just described.]

Frog-cat it is, then. [Rey sends the claw towards the desired plush.

[Too bad that claw just barely scrapes its ear before pulling back up. But Rey doesn't seem too bothered, as she's already taking out another coin.]

Sometimes you have to move them around a few times before you can actually catch what you want. No big deal.